Why Are Bonds and Stocks Acting Strangely?

The past week saw a dynamic in financial markets that, not long ago, would have been deemed quite unusual: Prices of all kinds of assets, from safe government bonds to risky stocks, rose together. German bunds and U.S. Treasuries gained, pushing yields lower, as the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index approached its all-time high.

The movements continued to confound the once-traditional pattern, in which bond prices rise and stock prices fall when investors expect the economy to perform poorly, and vice versa. There are various explanations, some more consequential than others.

One interpretation is that investors expect hyperactive central bankers to remain their best friends, buoying markets with continued unconventional policies. Last week’s disappointing economic data out of the U.S. and Europe would support this view, putting pressure on the Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank to be more accommodative than they otherwise would.

By demonstrating a consistent willingness and ability to contain market volatility and bolster the prices of financial assets, essentially divorcing equity performance from that of the underlying economy, central bankers have managed to bring more money off the sidelines and into the market. Lower borrowing costs have also boosted companies’ actual profitability, allowing them to return more money to shareholders in the form of dividends and share buybacks, as has the notion that we are in a lower historical interest-rate paradigm.

That’s the optimistic view. It is also valid and, given how well it has played out, deeply entrenched in markets. But it may be only part of a less comforting explanation relating to the view that, at current valuations, bond investors may be reacting to something that the stock market has yet to recognize.

Bond investors tend to be more risk averse than equity investors, and thus reposition earlier in response to a higher probability of a market selloff. This is in part because they are more focused on the macroeconomic picture, and in part because bonds have a different risk-reward profile: They ultimately pay only their face value, whereas stocks can keep going up.

This interpretation is bolstered by the fact that the stock market is also subject to demand influences that could prove temporary. The boom in merger and acquisitions, for example, has pumped a lot of cash into the market, helping to push prices higher than what the performance of the economy would justify.

If this complementary interpretation is correct, it’s just a matter of time before the correlation between risky and riskless assets starts returning to its historical pattern. The hard part is specifying the timing, especially as it relates to a crucial psychological question: When will investors lose faith in central banks’ ability to keep bolstering the economy through higher financial asset prices?

To contact the writer of this article: Mohamed A. El-Erian at

M.El-Erian@bloomberg.net.

Source ::  http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2014-08-18/why-are-bonds-and-stocks-acting-strangely

Related Posts

  • 63
    Why would anyone want to buy a bond that last longer than they do? These ultra-long-dated assets fell out of favor in the fallout from the financial crisis, as investors shifted to shorter-duration bonds to protect them against unpredictable spikes in interest rates. But now the "century bond" is returning…
    Tags: bonds, bond, investors, tend, week, government, companies, pay, earlier, assets
  • 63
    On Thursday Mohamed A. El-Erian was on CNBC`s Halftime Report and he said something that a lot of people have been saying regarding the bond market, and it needs to be cleared up, because the amount of poor understanding regarding the bond market by people who make their living, i.e.,…
    Tags: bond, market, el-erian, mohamed, lot, financial, trading
  • 59
    All it takes is a few mouse clicks to buy shares in the Scout Unconstrained Bond Fund (SUBFX), an exchange-traded fund that tracks a concoction of debt tied to the government, financial firms, mortgage pools, and other entities. And all it takes is a few mouse clicks to sell—something that has begun…
    Tags: bond, bonds, financial, economic, federal, reserve, borrowing, bank, rise, central
  • 57
    Bond investors hungry for yield have pushed further and further into high-risk territory and Pimco sees five warning signals that credit markets are getting overly frothy. "The lower reaches of the credit market have become particularly stretched," Christian Stracke, global head of Pimco's credit research group, said in a note last…
    Tags: bond, market, week, high, lower, investors, markets, trading
  • 56
    (Reuters) - Argentina said on Tuesday it would meet with a mediator for the second time this week in the country's dispute with "holdout" investors, lifting market hopes for a deal needed to avoid another painful debt default. With the economy already in recession, President Cristina Fernandez's cash-strapped government has…
    Tags: bonds, government, bank, investors, market, economy, will, trading, bond